 |
| tourists in the Blue Mosque in Istanbul |
Tour guides in Turkey are licensed by the government and licensing requirements are stringent. Tourism is an important industry and the government wants to insure that tourists have good experiences so they’ll come back and so they’ll encourage their friends to visit Turkey too. Our guides (one in Istanbul and another in Kusadasi / Ephesus) were knowledgeable, friendly, flexible and spoke very good English.
They also talked quite a bit about Islam and Islam as it’s practiced in Turkey. I don’t know if that was required by the government or encouraged by their Imams or if they were just good Muslims who wanted to give a bunch of Americans a first-hand account of what their religion is and isn’t. I do know that while I’m no expert on Islam and Turkish history I’m not completely ignorant either, and neither guide said anything at odds with what I know.
 |
| preparing for worship in the Blue Mosque |
Turks are not Arabs. The Turkish language has its roots in Central Asia and is most closely related to Mongolian and Korean. Arabic is a Semitic language that originated in the Middle East.
It is illegal to wear “religious dress” in primary and secondary schools or if you’re working in a government office. Our guide in Istanbul said that 12% of Turkish women wear the hijab (headscarf). In Istanbul it looked closer to 50%, but many of those were – like us – tourists from other countries. In Kusadasi I might have seen two, leading me to suspect his figure of 12% is in the ballpark.
We saw women dressed in everything from burkas to miniskirts. Our guides emphasized that any woman in a burka was a tourist from some place like Saudi Arabia and not a Turk. Whether that’s true or not (and again, I suspect it is) it says something – something good – that the guides felt the need to emphasize it.
 |
| the ceiling of the Blue Mosque |
Our guides said that almost no one goes to the mosque every day and nothing stops at prayer time: traffic keeps moving, shops stay open, schools stay in class. The only thing that stops are tours of the mosques themselves – if you want to visit a mosque don’t go within a half hour on either side of prayer time. Restaurants remain open during Ramadan, the month during which Muslims fast from sunup till sundown.
Beer and wine are readily available – and easier to buy than in some parts of Texas. So is raki, a distilled liquor similar to Greek ouzo. The local beer and wine I had was good but unremarkable; I rarely drink hard liquor and didn’t try the raki.
We visited the Sultan Ahmed Mosque in Istanbul, usually known as the Blue Mosque. It was completed in 1616 and is – in its own way – as beautiful and ornate as any cathedral. It is a working mosque – tourists enter through a side door and a large section is roped off for worshippers only. Everyone is required to remove their shoes (plastic bags are provided for carrying them) and anyone whose dress is considered immodest (usually exposed shoulders or legs) will be given a wrap for cover. Women are not required to cover their heads.
 |
| Hagia Sophia |
 |
| Christian artwork in Hagia Sophia |
Had I visited Jordan or Kuwait or Saudi Arabia my experience of Islam would have been very different. Contrary to what many in this country believe, Islam is not a monolithic religion.
I had a great time in Turkey and I’m glad a first-hand look at Islam was part of it.
 |
| The Blue Mosque in Istanbul |
Yes, this was my impression too. I was in Istanbul for a week and Ankara for close to two. It reminded me very much of the American South where religion soaks into even the weathered boards of the buildings. Islam in Turkey is part of the air you breathe. I didn't find it to be oppressive -- just omnipresent. The strange harmony of the many voices calling the city to prayer five times a day quickly became a sweet reminder for reflection for me even though I couldn't understand the words. "Pause. Breathe. Think about your soul," they seemed to say. Usually a comfortable lull would fall into the conversation as the Turks around me would take a sip of black coffee or a long thoughtful drag on their cigarette. Then we would all continue, refreshed and renewed. Christian iconography became something rare and a little exciting to spot. Every time we would pass by some Byzantine representation of Christ, my hosts would tease, "Look, there's your friend!" And that's how it felt. "Hi, pal," I'd say to the pictures of Jesus as if he was a long-lost college roommate. "Nice to see you again."
ReplyDeleteAs far as the wearing of the hajib goes, you have to remember, conservative religion in Turkey is linked to conservative politics. Liberal, progressive Turks can be as agitated by the sight of someone in traditional dress as a Unitarian can be irked by the sight of someone from Westboro Baptist. Religion there -- like here -- is wrapped up in politics, culture, and power.
Kelly, thanks for adding your experiences and impressions to mine. It strengthens my belief that what I saw and felt was authentic and not just whitewashing for tourists.
ReplyDeleteWhile I was in Egypt, and not Turkey, I found many similarities between your experiences and mine. Like Turkey, while Islam does permiate the fabric of Egypt, I never found it oppresive. Although apparently the mullahins in Egypt are louder, because I was routinely woken up by the call to prayer. :-)
ReplyDeleteWhen we toured sites, many with damage to the ancient icons, my guides were always quick to point out that the damage had been done before, often centuries before, Islam came to Egypt.
Many of my friends never or rarely wore hijab, and you would see many women on the streets without it. If you chose to wear it, fine, but if not that was fine too. You could always tell who was visiting from Saudi, or Jordan, or Ethiopia by what version of covering they were wearing.
You would of course wear a headscarf to mosque, but otherwise not so much. Prayer was similar, if it was morning prayer most observed it, but nothing stops in Cairo, or Alexandria, or Aswan even for prayer. If you want to, feel free, but we aren't stoping the bus as it were. :-)